17-Apr-2025
Presto Instruments
Impact testing is an essential process in material science to check how much force a material can handle. It can check how much energy can be taken before it bends or breaks. Two of the most commonly used devices for this purpose are the Charpy impact tester and the Izod impact tester.
Both are designed to measure the impact resistance of materials, but they differ in terms of sample placement and testing setup. Understanding these differences is necessary for choosing the appropriate test method for specific applications.
A Charpy Impact Tester measures the amount of impact energy absorbed by a material as it fractures. In the Charpy test, a notched specimen is placed horizontally, supported at both ends and struck behind the notch with a swinging hammer.
This configuration is built to replicate a rapid impact, such as a sudden hit or collision. The energy is taken in when the material breaks, which helps measure how tough the material is and how well it resists sudden impacts.
The perfect example of a Charp Tester can be a pendulum, which has a specific mass and length. It is raised to a set height and then dropped to impact the notched specimen.
The formula for the Charpy Tester is:
Here, E = Energy absorbed by the specimen (in joules)
m = Mass of the pendulum (kg)
g = Acceleration due to gravity (9.81 m/s²)
h₀ = Initial height of the pendulum before impact (m)
hf = Final height of the pendulum after breaking the specimen (m)
An Izod Tester is a device used to measure the toughness of materials, particularly plastics, under impact. It strikes the sample with a rapid force and records the energy it absorbs when it fractures. In this test, the sample is positioned vertically, and the impact is delivered to the top of the sample, with the notch pointing towards the striker.
Example: Think of a plastic part in a car bumper. The Izod test hits a sample to see if it can handle small crashes. This helps makers build safer bumpers for drivers.
The formula for the Izod impact tester is:
Energy Absorbed = Potential Energy (before impact) – Potential Energy (after impact)
Both the Izod and Charpy Testers are designed to test a material’s strength by delivering a rapid force, but the way the test is carried out is different. The Izod test holds the sample vertically and strikes it at the top, with the notch facing the striker. On the other hand, the Charpy test places the sample horizontally between two supports and strikes it behind the notch. Below is a table highlighting the key differences:
|
Feature |
Izod Impact Tester |
Charpy Impact Tester |
|
Sample Position |
The test specimen is mounted vertically, with the notch facing upwards. This setup simulates bending stress on one end. |
The specimen is placed horizontally, resting on two supports. This position creates a bending moment across the entire sample. |
|
Notch Direction |
The notch faces the striker, meaning the pendulum directly hits the notched side, initiating the fracture. |
The notch is on the opposite side of the striker, so the impact causes the material to break through the notch from behind. |
|
Support Type |
The specimen is clamped at one end only, resembling a cantilever. This makes it ideal for testing flexible materials. |
The specimen is supported at both ends, allowing it to flex at the point of impact, simulating real structural conditions. |
|
Impact Location |
The pendulum strikes the top portion of the specimen, just above the notch. |
The striker impacts directly behind the notch, forcing the crack to propagate through the weakened section. |
|
Testing Standards |
Common standards followed are ASTM D256 and ISO 180, mostly for plastics and polymeric materials. |
Standards include ASTM E23 and ISO 148, which are globally recognized for metallic materials. |
|
Primary Applications |
Widely used in quality control, research labs, and educational setups for testing plastics and soft materials. |
Common in industrial and structural testing, especially in automotive, aerospace, and metal fabrication. |
|
Energy Range |
Measures lower energy impacts, making it suitable for materials that absorb less energy like plastics. |
Designed for high energy impact testing, capable of breaking tough materials like steel or alloys. |
|
Pendulum Configuration |
Uses a lighter pendulum to measure smaller energy absorption accurately. |
Utilizes a heavier pendulum to deliver sufficient force for testing rigid, strong materials. |
|
Materials Tested |
Ideal for plastics, polymers, composites, and occasionally non-ferrous metals. |
Primarily used for metals and alloys, especially those used in structural applications. |
|
Notch Type |
Can use both V-notches and U-notches, depending on the material and testing standard. |
Typically uses a V-notch, which provides consistent results across metallic specimens. |
|
Fracture Observation |
Helps determine whether a material is ductile or brittle under sudden impact. |
Evaluates the energy required to fracture and the mode of failure in metals under high-stress impact. |
|
Sample Preparation |
Requires minimal preparation, as plastics are easier to cut and mount. |
Involves precision machining and measurement, as metals must meet strict dimensional tolerances. |
|
Mounting Method |
The sample is clamped vertically in a vise-like holder, with the free end exposed to the striker. |
The sample rests freely on two horizontal anvils, ensuring consistent impact at the center. |
|
Ease of Use |
Generally easier to operate and more accessible in educational or small-scale lab settings. |
Requires robust setup and calibration, typically found in industrial testing environments. |
|
Cost of Equipment |
Typically, less expensive due to its simpler design and lower force requirement. |
Usually more costly owing to its heavy-duty design and energy calibration systems. |
The decision between the Izod and Charpy Impact Test depends on your testing requirements, material type, and industry standards. If you are looking for a fast and cost-effective method to assess the impact resistance of flexible materials, the Izod Impact Test is the better option. Its vertical sample orientation and lower energy requirements make it an efficient choice.
Conversely, if you are conducting tests on metals or structural parts that require high energy testing and conformity to international standards such as ASTM E23, the Charpy Impact Test is the superior option. Knowledge of the variations in setup, energy range, and areas of application ensures proper material assessment and improves the reliability of your quality control measures.
Elevate your quality assurance process to new heights
At Presto, we take pride in being Global manufacturers of Laboratory Testing Instruments for different industries.